Android sends 20x more data to Google than iOS sends to Apple, study says

A woman under a thick blanket looks at her smartphone.
Enlarge / Insomnia folks and mobile-addiction ideas.

Whether or not you’ve an iPhone or an Android system, it’s repeatedly sending information together with your location, cellphone quantity, and native community particulars to Apple or Google. Now, a researcher has supplied a side-by-side comparability that means that, whereas each iOS and Android acquire handset information across the clock—even when units are idle, simply out of the field, or after customers have opted out—the Google cellular OS collects about 20 occasions as a lot information than its Apple competitor.

Each iOS and Android, researcher Douglas Leith from Trinity School in Eire stated, transmit telemetry information to their motherships even when a consumer hasn’t logged in or has explicitly configured privateness settings to decide out of such assortment. Each OSes additionally ship information to Apple and Google when a consumer does easy issues akin to inserting a SIM card or searching the handset settings display screen. Even when idle, every system connects to its back-end server on common each four.5 minutes.

Apps and extra

It wasn’t simply the OSes that despatched information to Apple or Google. Preinstalled apps or providers additionally made community connections, even once they hadn’t been opened or used. Whereas iOS routinely despatched Apple information from Siri, Safari, and iCloud, Android collected information from Chrome, YouTube, Google Docs, Safetyhub, Google Messenger, the system clock, and the Google search bar.

The desk under reveals a abstract of handset information despatched to Apple or Google when the consumer isn’t logged in:

Douglas Leith

The place Android stands out, Leith stated, is within the quantity of knowledge it collects. At startup, an Android system sends Google about 1MB of knowledge, in contrast with iOS sending Apple round 42KB. When idle, Android sends roughly 1MB of knowledge to Google each 12 hours, in contrast with iOS sending Apple about 52KB over the identical interval. Within the US alone, Android collectively gathers about 1.3TB of knowledge each 12 hours. Throughout the identical interval, iOS collects about 5.8GB.

Google disagrees

Google has contested the findings, saying that they’re primarily based on defective strategies for measuring the information that’s collected by every OS. The corporate additionally contended that information assortment is a core perform of any Web-connected system.

In an announcement, a spokesperson wrote:

We recognized flaws within the researcher’s methodology for measuring information quantity and disagree with the paper’s claims that an Android system shares 20 occasions extra information than an iPhone. Based on our analysis, these findings are off by an order of magnitude, and we shared our methodology considerations with the researcher earlier than publication.

This analysis largely outlines how smartphones work. Trendy automobiles repeatedly ship fundamental information about car elements, their security standing and repair schedules to automobile producers, and cell phones work in very comparable methods. This report particulars these communications, which assist be certain that iOS or Android software program is updated, providers are working as supposed, and that the cellphone is safe and operating effectively.

On background (which means Ars isn’t permitted to call or quote the spokesperson), the consultant stated that it’s inaccurate to say consumer can decide out of all telemetry information assortment by the Google OS. The Android Utilization and Diagnostics checkbox doesn’t cowl telemetry information that Google considers important for the system to function usually. Telemetry data collected by the Machine Configuration service, as an example, is required for updating and patching the OS.

The spokesperson additionally challenged the strategies the researcher used to measure the quantity of knowledge collected by iOS. The experimental setup they used didn’t seize sure forms of information, akin to UDP/QUIC site visitors, which is often transmitted by smartphones.

Apple representatives didn’t reply to an e mail in search of remark.

Round the clock assortment

Leith carried out his measurements utilizing a Google Pixel 2 operating Android 10 and an iPhone eight operating iOS 13.6.1. The iPhone was jailbroken utilizing the Checm8 exploit. The Pixel had Google Play providers enabled.

In all, the examine, accessible here, measured the quantity of knowledge the units collected:

  • on first startup following a manufacturing unit reset
  • when a SIM was inserted or eliminated
  • when a handset was idle
  • when the settings display screen was considered
  • when location was enabled or disabled
  • when the consumer logged in to the preinstalled app retailer

Leith stated the information assortment by each OSes is regarding as a result of it’s readily linked to a consumer’s title, e mail tackle, cost card information, and presumably to different units the consumer has. What’s extra, the fixed connections to back-end servers essentially reveals the IP tackle of the system and, by extension, the overall geographic location of the consumer.

“Presently there are few, if any, real looking choices for stopping this information sharing,” Leith wrote.